Massey’s Pizza Sports Bar & Wings

Reviews

• Lucas A.

  star star star star star 21 July 2026

  I believe this may be one of the best pizzas in Columbus for someone that's trying to eat healthy. The cauliflower pizza at Massey's is very good. The crust is supposedly low carb, although I'm not sure the specifics. I had the cauliflower pizza and their traditional wings. I was impressed by the taste and quality!

• Robert L.

  star star star star star 20 July 2026

  It's been awhile so I revisited Massey's and they didn't disappoint. I ordered take out of Godfather pizza and asked for extra sauce and they gave me plenty which is what I like.
  Takes time to cook but worth it.

• Nicholas G.

  star star star star star_border 14 July 2026

  I had one of the lunch specials.  A 8" one topping pizza & soda for $7.99.  I added in a side of 5 bone in buffalo garlic wings $5.99, celery & ranch $0.99.  My total bill ended up being $16.10
  The food was all very good and fresh.  The only mistake was I was served boneless wings instead of bone-in.  I chose not to complain and eat them anyway.  My waitress's name was Danyale W and she was awesome.  My soda never was empty, and she was super nice.  
  Definitely was a good experience and look forward to coming back sometime soon.

• Lauren S.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 14 July 2026

  Service is typically slow and the food isn't bad but nothing to write home about. I have family that loves coming here so I've been a few times and it's been the same general experience. No matter how busy, appetizers are cold. Their "famous pepperoni" pizza definitely does not look like the picture in the menu. Just a normal pizza to me. It's a bit bigger than a normal Massey's so that's convenient for large groups. There are definitely better pizza shops in Columbus but Grove City isn't there yet so it seems to be the highlight of the town.

• Christopher G.

  star star star star star 3 July 2026

  I dig this specific location the best. Unlike any other Massey's, this one sports a full service bar, big screen TVs, weekly events, and a a great outdoor patio. Place is clean and comfortable, and service is good, but the gleaming gem is their pie. Thinner crust, with the perfect amount/balance of fresh toppings/sauce/ cheese. They also cook the bottom with a slight coating of corn meal, which really sets it apart!
  
  Other fare is good too, all apps and sided (even if most likely frozen) are of high quality, and prepared well. Their subs are also killer too!
  
  My fav is their Supreme, which is pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, and green pepper, outstanding, and we highly recommend.